
I
stopped counting my rejection slips when they surpassed 1,000.
While a lesser man might weep with frustration, I have savored
every one since that first envelope returned from the New Yorker
in 1969 with an encouraging note from editor Howard Moss. Sure,
it hurts to get turned down. Each one takes a little slice out
of my. . .heart?. . .ego?. . .enthusiasm? But I'm not about to
give up. I don't write to get published even though I love when
it happens. I write because it excites me and makes me happy,
and is…well…fun, especially when I'm on to something I've never
done before. Nobody's ever done before. While not everything I
write is experimental, writing is for me an experiment of
language and meaning. I don't want to write what I've already
written.
I'm tough. I can take rejection, but that doesn't mean I don't
need a pick-me-up every now and then. Laurence Peter's The Peter
Principle (A title close to my heart) was rejected more than 30
times before
finding a publisher and selling 200,000 copies its first year.
Irving Stone's Lust for Life, rejected 16 times, sold more than
25 million copies and made an Academy Award winning film. And
poor Van Gogh, the subject of Stone's book, is alleged to have
sold just one painting during his lifetime. Talk about
rejection!
When I receive bad mail, I take out my copy of
Rotten Rejections
and remember I am not alone—
- Moby Dick - "We regret to say that our united opinion is
entirely against the book as we do not think it would be at all
suitable for the Juvenile Market."
- The Good Earth - "Regret the American Public is not interested
in anything on China."
- The Diary of Anne Frank - "The girl doesn't, it seems to me,
have a special perception or feeling which would lift that book
above the ‘curiosity' level."
- The Spy Who Came in from the Cold - "You're welcome to le Carré—he hasn't got any future."
- The Blessing Way (Tony Hillerman) - "If you insist on
rewriting this, get rid of all that Indian stuff."
- Animal Farm - "It is impossible to sell animal stories in the
U.S.A."
And of course, there's poor John Kennedy Toole whose novel,
A
Confederacy of Dunces, was rejected so many times he grew
despondent and committed suicide. His mother refused to give up
and continued to send the manuscript out, finally winning the
support of Walker Percy. It ended up winning the 1980 Pulitzer
prize for fiction!
Poet, novelist and
Getaway Faculty Member Renée Ashley
doesn't give up. She called in October to say her poetry
manuscript, Basic Heart, was just chosen by the Texas Review
Press as the winner of the 2008 X. J. Kennedy Prize.
Congratulations, I said, truly happy that her fourth book of
poems would soon be published. Renée never gave up, even after
her manuscript was rejected 152 times!
Read
how she did it.
Next year, I will pull all my rejections notes out of their dark
corners and have a 40th Anniversary party. Why celebrate
rejection? I'm still alive and I'm still writing. And besides, I
also have a few hundred acceptances notes which I would not have
had I given up.